Harry Shum Jr., His Mother’s First “I Love You,” and a Dance Honoring Naya River

Dance Mogul Magazine · Culture · DWTS Season 35

Harry Shum Jr., His Mother’s First “I Love You,” and a Dance Honoring Naya Rivera

When dance opens the heart: in one week, a perfect score, a mother who paints, and a quickstep for a friend he lost.

November 18, 2026 · Dance Mogul Magazine

Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson, Dancing with the Stars Season
Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson, Season 35. Photo: Disney/Andrew Eccles.

The phone call Harry Shum Jr. described was ordinary in almost every way. His mother, Julia, wanted to talk about Dancing with the Stars. She had watched his Disney Night routine, a jazz number to “Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious” that earned a perfect 40, and she had watched it more than once. She is a painter, and she told him that watching it felt the way she feels when she paints. Then she did something he said she had never done about anything he had made: she talked through the dance in detail. As the call ended, she told him she knew he was tired, and she said she loved him.

Shum is 44. In an Instagram video shared in the days before the semifinals, he said it was the first time he had heard those words from her. “In certain cultures,” he explained, parents rarely say it; they show it. Hearing it, he said, unlocked something in him.

A week later he danced a quickstep to “Valerie” for Naya Rivera, his late Glee co-star, and the judges gave it three 10s. By the end of the same night he had been eliminated. This is the story of that week, and of what dance did in it that a scoreboard cannot show.

A Mother Who Paints, a Son Who Dances

The details of the call matter because of who was speaking. Julia Shum is a visual artist, and the comparison she reached for was her own medium. A painter knows what it is to build something one decision at a time, to feel the moment a composition starts to hold together. When she said watching her son dance felt like painting, she was not offering a compliment from the outside; she was recognizing a process she understands from the inside.

That is the quiet power of the arts between generations. Two people can share a language of making long before they share a language of saying. A parent who rarely says “I love you” may still show it for decades: in sacrifice, in attention, in the hours spent watching a child’s work. What changed on that call was not the love. It was that a dance gave her a way to put it into words, and she took it. Shum said she told him to keep going and do his best, then closed with the line he has repeated since: “I love you, goodnight.”

Shum framed the moment carefully, and DMM follows his framing. He described a cultural pattern, not a failing: in many families, affection is expressed through action and the words stay unspoken. Hearing them for the first time at 44, he said, was growth. For readers whose parents also show rather than tell, the story offers no judgment, only a reminder that the bridge can still be built, sometimes by the work itself.

The routine his mother watched

What to Watch For

The jazz routine moves at the speed of a tongue twister. Watch how Shum keeps the long word’s rhythm in his body, landing accents on the syllables, and how Jenna Johnson builds the number from musical theater shapes rather than ballroom holds. This is the kind of clean, playful precision a painter would recognize as composition.

Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson’s Disney Night jazz to “Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious,” 40/40, November 2, 2026. Video: Dancing with the Stars/ABC on YouTube. Watch on YouTube

“Valerie” and the Memory of Glee

Before he was a Season 35 contestant, Shum was Mike Chang, the dancer of Glee, the musical series that sent a generation of viewers back to show choirs and dance classes. In the 2010 episode “Special Education,” Naya Rivera, as Santana Lopez, sang a solo cover of “Valerie,” with Shum dancing alongside Heather Morris. Rivera later sang it again in the show’s 100th episode. Rivera died in July 2020, at 33.

Shum had told People in October that Glee fans would see references in his routines; on Yacht Rock Night he wore a mustache recalling Mike Chang’s turn to the same Hall & Oates song. Before his first DWTS appearance, Morris phoned him, and the two reminisced about dancing with Rivera; Morris told him he and Johnson would do well and that she watched every week. The semifinal assignment, a quickstep to “Valerie,” turned those references into a full tribute.

It also required precision about what audiences would hear. Shum and Johnson posted a rehearsal clip set to Rivera’s vocals, and Shum clarified in the comments that on the night, the DWTS band would play the Glee arrangement live. Rivera’s recorded voice was not used in the ballroom. The tribute lived in the arrangement, the choreography and the memory the audience brought with them.

Inside the Performance: Music, Movement and Meaning

Inside the Performance: Five Elements

Music
“Valerie” began as a song by the Zutons before Mark Ronson and Amy Winehouse turned it into a retro-soul hit with a driving backbeat and bright horns; Glee reshaped it again for Rivera’s voice. The DWTS band played the Glee arrangement live. Its relentless forward pulse suits the quickstep, the fastest of the traveling ballroom dances, where quick-quick-slow rhythms push the couple around the floor.

Movement
The quickstep’s test is a quiet upper body over very busy feet: hops, runs and lock steps carried inside a closed hold. Inaba praised Shum’s growth in the style and called his technique flawless, Tonioli called the routine impeccable, and Hough said it was how you quickstep into the finals. For a trained commercial dancer, the achievement is restraint: energy kept inside the frame.

Atmosphere
The judges gave it three 10s, his second perfect score of the night after a paso doble Inaba called the paso doble of the season. After the dance, Shum told co-host Julianne Hough that DWTS feels synonymous with Glee and that dancing to Naya’s version meant a great deal to many people, including him. He ended with a line to Rivera herself.

Human significance
Shum had danced to this song beside Rivera 16 years earlier. Returning to it as a 44-year-old competitor let the routine carry two timelines at once: the young dancer on Glee and the artist he became. Johnson, his partner, said in the rehearsal package that viewers had waited all season for a Glee moment; Shum said in rehearsal that she was his first formal dance teacher.

Reader takeaway
Familiar music changes when memory enters it. A song can be a hit, a television moment and a memorial at the same time, and a dance can hold all three without explaining them. That is something any family that plays a loved one’s favorite song at a gathering already knows.

“We miss you, baby girl.”

— Harry Shum Jr., to Naya Rivera, after the semifinal quickstep (as reported by the USA TODAY Network, November 17, 2026)

The tribute

What to Watch For

Watch the closed hold: Shum and Johnson stay connected through every hop and run while their heads and shoulders stay calm. Listen for the moment the band’s arrangement lifts, and notice that the choreography keeps traveling instead of stopping for tricks. The memory is in the music; the technique is in the frame.

Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson’s semifinal quickstep to “Valerie,” 30/30, November 17, 2026. Video: Dancing with the Stars/ABC on YouTube. Watch on YouTube

A Perfect 60, and Then the Vote

Shum and Johnson finished the semifinals on 60/60, level with Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov at the top of the leaderboard. When the judges’ scores were combined with viewer votes, they were eliminated. ABC does not publish vote totals, so no one outside the production can say how close the result was or why the vote fell as it did. DMM will not guess.

What the record does show is a complete arc. Shum opened the season with a 21/30 cha-cha, drew the season’s first 40/40 on Horror Movie Night, scored 40 again on Disney Night, and closed with two perfect 30s. In DMM’s season record he leaves with the highest cumulative judges’ total of Season 35. It was a season with hard weeks too: after an October samba drew sharp criticism from Carrie Ann Inaba, Shum posted a message asking viewers to remember the joy of dance and the people behind the competition.

Immediately after his exit, Shum told E! News he oddly felt at ease and that they had accomplished everything they wanted to. He thanked Johnson for handling the noise outside with grace and for teaching him things he had only dreamed of learning.

DMM Dance Lens

All season DMM tracked Shum as the transfer test: could a trained commercial dancer rebuild his habits for ballroom? The scores answer yes. The elimination answers a different question, one the panel never asks: what an audience is attached to over ten weeks. Both are real. A perfect score measures one night of dancing; it cannot measure a mother’s words on the phone, or what a song means to the people who loved the woman who sang it.

What We Can Take Away

Art can do what conversation sometimes cannot. A painter found words for her love through her son’s dancing; a dancer found a way to speak to a friend who is gone. Neither moment depended on the competition’s outcome, and neither was diminished by it.

For young dancers, the lesson is practical as well as emotional. The work you make becomes a language other people can use, sometimes people who have never told you how they feel. Make it carefully. Someone may be watching it more than once.

What Comes Next

Shum leaves the competition one week before the finale, but not the stage he has worked on for more than two decades as a dancer and actor. The five finalists, Tatyana Ali, Ezra Frech, Amber Glenn, Maura Higgins and Connor Wood, dance on Tuesday, November 24, in a three-hour finale airing live in every U.S. time zone. ABC had not announced whether eliminated couples will appear in the finale when this article was published; DMM will report it if they do.

Sources & Attribution

His mother’s first “I love you”: Entertainment Weekly, November 16, 2026; People, November 17; Just Jared, November 17.

“Valerie,” Glee and Naya Rivera: Page Six, November 17, 2026; E! News, November 18; Entertainment Weekly, November 17; USA TODAY Network, November 17. Earlier Glee references: People, October 11. October statement: Entertainment Weekly, October 16.

Scores, judges’ comments and result: ABC7/On The Red Carpet, November 18, 2026; TheWrap, November 17; E! News, November 18. Season scores: DMM’s Season 35 Live Dashboard. Videos: Dancing with the Stars official YouTube channel. Analysis is original DMM editorial; no rehearsal access is claimed.

© 2026 Dance Mogul Magazine LLC · Inspiring Self-Empowerment Through Dance Culture
Dancing with the Stars is a trademark of its owner. Dance Mogul Magazine is an independent publication and is not affiliated with ABC or Disney.

No Comments Yet

Leave a Reply